When September rolls around, pumpkin spice and cozy flavors take over everything from lattes to candles and SusieCakes is no exception. Known for their rich cakes and classic bakes, the bakery kicks off fall with a rotating lineup of seasonal treats. Each month brings something new, from September’s pumpkin and banana flavors to October’s Halloween-inspired sweets and November’s holiday classics. These limited-time desserts carry the spirit of fall straight through the holiday season, making SusieCakes a spot worth revisiting as the months go by. The September treats are available through Sept. 28, giving fans the whole month to try them before the menu rotates again.
Pumpkin Spice Latte Cupcake – $5.49 each
The Pumpkin Spice Latte Cupcake is a bold entry into SusieCakes’ fall offerings. The flavor is intense yet balanced, blending warm pumpkin spice with smooth coffee notes. The cake is topped with pure coffee buttercream frosting and finished with a sprinkling of cinnamon and sugar, bringing together the spice and latte flavors. Moist and flavorful, each bite evokes the essence of fall. For those seeking a cozy, seasonal indulgence, this cupcake delivers.
Banana Chocolate Chip Cake – $8.75 each
After more than six years, the Banana Chocolate Chip Cake has returned to SusieCakes’ seasonal lineup—and it’s worth the wait. Made with ripe bananas and semi-sweet chocolate chips in a four-layer cake, it’s frosted with SusieCakes’ signature cream cheese frosting and decorated with brown jimmies along the base. The cake is airy, rich without being overwhelming and has a perfect balance of banana and chocolate in every bite. While the cream cheese frosting may be strong for some palates, it complements the cake and brings all the layers together. Generous in size and staying fresh for days, this cake offers a satisfying and indulgent experience. Though slightly pricey, the quality and portion size make it worth trying.
Susiecakes’ September fall lineup proves that the bakery knows how to capture the essence of the season. From the pumpkin-forward latte cupcake to the nostalgic return of the banana chocolate chip cake, the seasonal offerings are cozy, flavorful and indulgent. With new treats arriving each month, SusieCakes provides a reason to revisit throughout fall and into the holidays, ensuring that every bite feels like a celebration of the season.
